8 Best Restaurants in Jericho, NY

Jericho, NY, is a gem for food enthusiasts, offering an array of dining options that cater to every palate. From cozy cafes serving up comfort food to elegant restaurants specializing in gourmet cuisines, Jericho is a destination for those who appreciate good food in great settings. This guide explores the finest eateries in Jericho, ensuring that whether you're a resident or a visitor, your dining options are nothing short of exceptional.

Fanatico Italian Bistro & Bar stands out with its authentic Italian cuisine, served in a warm and inviting atmosphere. Known for its robust menu featuring homemade pasta, thin pizzas, and an array of seafood and meat preparations, Fanatico provides a perfect blend of traditional and modern Italian dining. The restaurant’s bar scene also makes it a popular spot for an evening out, offering a selection of fine wines and cocktails.

For those searching for a taste of Portugal, Lisbon Cafe offers a rich culinary experience with its meticulously prepared Portuguese dishes. From the signature seafood paella to the succulent steaks and chops, each meal is a celebration of flavor. The cafe's intimate setting and attentive service make it an ideal choice for a special occasion or a casual meal with family and friends.

The Milleridge Inn is not just a restaurant; it's a historic landmark that offers a unique dining experience. This charming inn serves traditional American cuisine in a rustic, colonial-style setting, complete with a quaint village and seasonal events. Whether you’re enjoying a hearty Sunday brunch or a festive holiday meal, The Milleridge Inn provides a picturesque backdrop and delicious food that make every visit memorable.

Market Bistro is a favorite among locals for its innovative approach to American cuisine. This restaurant prides itself on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients to craft dishes that are both flavorful and visually appealing. The menu changes seasonally, offering diners a taste of the best produce and meats available. The cozy ambiance and friendly service are just the icing on the cake.

The Cotillion is renowned for its exquisite Indian cuisine and elegant banquet facilities. Perfect for fine dining and special events, this restaurant offers a menu filled with aromatic and flavorful dishes prepared using traditional Indian cooking techniques. The luxurious decor and attentive service ensure a sophisticated and satisfying meal.

Opus Mediterranean Restaurant offers an elegant dining experience in the heart of Jericho. The open-concept kitchen allows diners to watch as chefs prepare succulent steakhouse classics and fresh seafood dishes like Prime, Dry-Aged Porterhouse for two, Chilean Sea Bass, and Grilled Branzino. The restaurant also boasts an extensive wine list, featuring over 500 wines, which perfectly complement any meal. The lush garden and terrace seating enhance the ambiance, making it an ideal venue for both casual dining and private events. The restaurant is also certified by the Official Kobe Beef Association, ensuring top-quality cuisine. 

Tap Room is a favorite local gastropub in Jericho, offering a laid-back atmosphere perfect for casual gatherings. The menu features elevated pub fare crafted in a scratch kitchen, complemented by handcrafted cocktails and a selection of 24 beers on tap. The venue is also known for its lively environment with live music, DJs, and weekend brunch offerings. Sports enthusiasts will appreciate the numerous TVs, making it an excellent spot for watching games and enjoying a vibrant social setting.

For authentic New York-style pizza, Mulberry St. Pizza is a must-visit. This pizzeria serves up generous slices and whole pies topped with everything from classic cheese to gourmet combinations. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or sitting down with family, Mulberry St. Pizza delivers both great food and a lively atmosphere.

Jericho’s diverse dining scene offers something for everyone, from cozy cafes to gourmet restaurants. Each establishment contributes its unique flavors and atmospheres, making Jericho a true dining destination on Long Island.

If you’re considering moving to Jericho or are interested in local real estate opportunities, reach out to The Michelle Zhao Group. Their team is dedicated to providing expert guidance and personalized service to help you find the perfect home in this community. Connect with them today to learn more about living and dining in the wonderful town of Jericho, NY.